Moat AIGet Started
LLYNYSEHealthcare — Pharmaceuticals

Eli Lilly and Company

Warren Buffett Score Analysis

4 of 8 Buffett criteria met · Watchlist · Data as of June 2026

6.5

/ 10

Watchlist

Key Financial Metrics

P/E Ratio

189.2×

Trailing 12M

ROE

5.6%

Return on Equity

Debt / Equity

1.11×

Lower is safer

Net Margin

2.3%

Profitability

Rev. Growth (5yr)

21.6%

CAGR

FCF

$9B

Annual free cash flow

Buffett Criteria Checklist

Eight criteria Warren Buffett consistently applies. Each criterion is scored; the total drives the Buffett Score above.

Consistent Earnings Growth

Pass

Lilly has stayed profitable across cycles while the obesity and diabetes franchise accelerated scale.

Multi-cycle earnings base

Return on Equity (ROE)

Fail

ROE of 5.6% is well below Buffett's 15% threshold as heavy manufacturing buildout compresses returns.

5.6% TTM

Debt / Equity Ratio

Fail

Debt-to-equity above 1.0 is elevated for a Buffett-style quality screen.

1.11×

~

Net Profit Margin

Watch

Reported margin is unusually thin for pharma because capacity expansion and launch spend are hitting near-term profitability.

2.3% TTM

Revenue Growth (5-Year CAGR)

Pass

Sales have compounded rapidly as Mounjaro, Zepbound, and the broader diabetes franchise scaled.

21.6% CAGR

~

Valuation (P/E vs. Intrinsic Value)

Watch

A 189× trailing P/E is expensive on reported earnings, though the multiple is distorted by temporary margin compression.

189.2× TTM P/E

Durable Competitive Moat

Pass

Patents, clinical data, payer relationships, and endocrinology distribution create a real moat around Lilly's GLP-1 franchise.

Intangible-asset moat

Free Cash Flow Generation

Pass

Lilly still generated nearly $9B in annual free cash flow despite aggressive manufacturing expansion.

~$9.0B annual FCF

Score Breakdown

6.5 / 10.0 pts

Pass Watch (half points) Fail (no points)

Moat AI

See our full AI-screened portfolio of picks → $29/mo

The LLY analysis above is free. Moat AI runs this same checklist weekly across hundreds of stocks using a 4-stage AI pipeline — macro trends → sector impacts → stock picks → Buffett valuation. Subscribers get the full ranked list, exact tickers, entry signals, and copy-portfolio instructions.

Cancel anytime · No lock-in · <$1/day

Competitive Moat Analysis

Intangible-asset moatScale moatDistribution moat

Lilly's moat is built on intangible assets and distribution depth. Patents and clinical data protect the core portfolio, but the bigger advantage is commercial: Lilly already has deep endocrinology relationships, payer access, and a global diabetes footprint. That gives Mounjaro and Zepbound a lower-friction path into formularies and physician workflows than a single-product challenger would have. In obesity and diabetes, that installed base compounds the value of each new indication.

Sector & Macro Context (2026)

In 2026 the GLP-1 market is expanding faster than supply can be built. Lilly is spending aggressively on fill-finish capacity and new manufacturing sites, which supports long-run volume growth but temporarily drags on ROE and reported margin. Pricing pressure from payers, reimbursement scrutiny, and regulatory timing for new indications are the key external swing factors. This is a demand-rich market, but execution still matters more than narrative.

Investment Thesis

Eli Lilly's Mounjaro represents the strongest competitive threat to Novo Nordisk in GLP-1 obesity treatment, with potentially superior efficacy driving market share gains. The company's established diabetes franchise provides cross-selling opportunities and payer relationships for obesity indication expansion. Manufacturing investments in Europe and aggressive pricing strategy position Lilly to capture significant share of the expanding obesity treatment market.

Key Risks

  • Manufacturing supply bottlenecks
  • Competitive pricing pressure
  • Regulatory approval delays
  • Market saturation concerns
  • ROE of 5.6% remains below the ideal Buffett-style quality range

Moat AI

See our full AI-screened portfolio of picks → $29/mo

The LLY analysis above is free. Moat AI runs this same checklist weekly across hundreds of stocks using a 4-stage AI pipeline — macro trends → sector impacts → stock picks → Buffett valuation. Subscribers get the full ranked list, exact tickers, entry signals, and copy-portfolio instructions.

Cancel anytime · No lock-in · <$1/day

More Free Buffett Score Reports

Legal Disclaimer

This analysis is for informational and educational purposes only. It does not constitute investment advice, a recommendation to buy or sell any security, or an offer to provide investment advisory services. All financial data is sourced from public filings and may not be current. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. Always conduct your own due diligence and consult a qualified financial advisor before making investment decisions.